Review Process
Eligibility and Completeness Review
All applications must be reviewed for eligibility and completeness and confirmed by the Office of the Senior Vice Chancellor for Research before the applications move forward into the “Review Phase”.
- If the number of internal applicants exceeds the number of allowable submissions to the sponsoring agency:
- an internal review process will be used to select the applicants or nominees who will be permitted to proceed with the submission. Peer reviewers are chosen by the Office of the Senior Vice Chancellor for Research specific to the focus of the sponsoring agency.
- The reviewers rank internal applications using a defined rubric* to identify which applicants or nominees will have the best chance of being funded. Reviewers are anonymous, and their identities are never shared with applicants. The review process lasts approximately three weeks. Although this may vary depending on sponsor deadlines.
- Once the review process is complete, Research Development Resources & Services will notify the applicants or nominees via an email from InfoReady within two business days to ensure that the selected applicant or nominee has as much time as possible to prepare their proposal for submission.
- If the number of applicants does not exceed the number of allowable submissions, no internal competition will be necessary.
Selected applications or nominees will be provided with relevant deadline information via an email from InfoReady. The applicants or nominees permitted to proceed should consult with their departmental grant administrators to determine appropriate next steps for submission.
If a selected applicant decides not to submit, Research Development must be notified at researchdev@pitt.edu as soon as possible.
*Rubric:
- Alignment with the mission of the solicitation
- Approach and Design
- Significance of the Project and Potential Impact
- How well the pre-application describes the intended project
- Does the PI have the appropriate training and experience
- Post-Nomination: [PLACEHOLDER: do we want to put in some language here stating that we will help them prepare their submissions; get letters; etc…]